clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Top 25 analysis: Are you a fan of scoreboard watching?

Top 25 Polls Letterman
Top 25 Polls Letterman

Boise State fell behind Stanford in the latest BCS standings, which is cause for all of Bronco Nation to get out there and passive aggressively root against the Cardinal in all its remaining games. Right?

Well, that's one option. Scoreboard-watching is a classic non-AQ pastime, provided there is a point, like rankings or bowl berths or really, really hating Oregon. An alternative would be to sit back, relax, and enjoy watching Boise State football, apart from the outcomes of games across the country. Which route are you taking this year?

Scoreboard-watching is a different animal this season because of Boise State's lot in college football life and its past history of getting snubbed. Most Bronco fans would be scoreboard-watching in hopes that BSU would sneak into the Top Two in the BCS standings and get a spot in the BCS national championship game. But is that even a possibility this season?

First, there's the fact that college football has made things clear in the past that the Broncos are not really welcome at the tip-top of the polls. Second, there's prevailing wisdom that Boise State does not have what it takes schedule-wise (thanks, New Mexico!) and competition-wise (Alabama, LSU, Oklahoma, and others are just too good) to pull off the national championship game berth.


Still, even with the odds in mind, a scoreboard-watcher would likely say: "Well, teams won't wind up ahead of the Broncos with two losses now, will they?" And therein lies the scoreboard-watcher's drug. There is always a chance that the teams you need to lose could very well lose. So why not root against them?

Here are the remaining schedules for Alabama, LSU, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, and Stanford, with big games highlighted in bold.

Alabama

  • vs. LSU
  • @ Mississippi State
  • vs. Georgia Southern
  • @ Auburn
  • SEC championship

LSU

  • @ Alabama
  • vs. Western Kentucky
  • @ Ole Miss
  • Arkansas
  • SEC championship

Oklahoma

  • Texas A&M
  • @ Baylor
  • Iowa State
  • @ Oklahoma State
  • Big 12 championship

Oklahoma State

  • Kansas State
  • @ Texas Tech
  • @ Iowa State
  • Oklahoma
  • Big 12 championship

Stanford

  • @ Oregon State
  • Oregon
  • Cal
  • Notre Dame
  • Pac 12 championship

You can root for multiple losses for each of these teams or you can take a sunnier approach: Root for Boise State. The Broncos will be guaranteed a BCS bowl if they win the rest of their games, and a BCS bowl - no matter who else loses across the country - would probably be as good as it's going to get anyway.

Tell me which side you fall on in the comments.

Official Top 25 polls - AP, USA Today, and BCS Poll

More poll data available at the ESPN website.


Football Rankings

Rank Team Points
1 LSU Tigers 1439
2 Alabama Crimson Tide 1401
3 Oklahoma St. Cowboys 1305
4 Stanford Cardinal 1278
5 Boise St. Broncos 1241
6 Oregon Ducks 1148
7 Oklahoma Sooners 1096
8 Arkansas Razorbacks 1035
9 Nebraska Cornhuskers 976
10 South Carolina Gamecocks 861
11 Clemson Tigers 851
12 Virginia Tech Hokies 755
13 Michigan Wolverines 718
14 Houston Cougars 611
15 Michigan St. Spartans 586
16 Penn St. Nittany Lions 553
17 Kansas St. Wildcats 536
18 Georgia Bulldogs 446
19 Wisconsin Badgers 420
20 Arizona St. Sun Devils 384
21 USC Trojans 323
22 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 230
23 Cincinnati Bearcats 128
24 West Virginia Mountaineers 111
25 Auburn Tigers 107
Rank Team Avg
1 LSU Tigers .973
2 Alabama Crimson Tide .959
3 Oklahoma St. Cowboys .931
4 Stanford Cardinal .861
5 Boise St. Broncos .852
6 Oklahoma Sooners .776
7 Arkansas Razorbacks .703
8 Oregon Ducks .691
9 South Carolina Gamecocks .617
10 Nebraska Cornhuskers .615
11 Clemson Tigers .596
12 Virginia Tech Hokies .568
13 Houston Cougars .469
14 Kansas St. Wildcats .460
15 Michigan Wolverines .451
16 Penn St. Nittany Lions .402
17 Michigan St. Spartans .307
18 Georgia Bulldogs .289
19 Arizona St. Sun Devils .236
20 Wisconsin Badgers .215
21 Texas Longhorns .211
22 Auburn Tigers .149
23 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets .127
24 West Virginia Mountaineers .113
25 Southern Miss. Golden Eagles .094
Rank Team Points
1 LSU Tigers 1,457
2 Alabama Crimson Tide 1,434
3 Stanford Cardinal 1,323
4 Oklahoma St. Cowboys 1,314
5 Boise St. Broncos 1,237
6 Oregon Ducks 1,175
7 Oklahoma Sooners 1,117
8 Arkansas Razorbacks 1,046
9 Nebraska Cornhuskers 973
10 South Carolina Gamecocks 919
11 Virginia Tech Hokies 871
12 Clemson Tigers 779
13 Michigan Wolverines 734
14 Houston Cougars 679
15 Penn St. Nittany Lions 646
16 Michigan St. Spartans 528
17 Wisconsin Badgers 463
18 Arizona St. Sun Devils 445
19 Kansas St. Wildcats 440
20 Georgia Bulldogs 410
21 West Virginia Mountaineers 270
22 Cincinnati Bearcats 232
23 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 193
24 Southern Miss. Golden Eagles 160
25 Texas Longhorns 122

Official OBNUG Top 25 poll

If you can't see the image below, go to Google Docs to get the full OBNUG Top 25 breakdown.


Others receiving votes: no one

Explanation: The OBNUG Top 25 poll uses a points-based ranking system to determine its order. Each pollster receives 50 points to distribute to teams as he or she sees fit. The max points that a voter can award a team is 10 points. The minimum is one point. There is no voting for Idaho allowed.

Not only do OBNUG voters love putting the Broncos higher than everyone else (BSU is No. 5 in all major polls), we also love putting fellow non-BCS teams way higher than others. Houston, the large-and-in-charge member of the CUSA, moves three spots up to No. 8 in this week's blogpoll on the strength of a blowout win over what's-their-names. See? We aren't just being biased about our own non-AQ team. We are being biased about all non-AQ teams (Southern Miss is No. 18 according to OBNUG, and No. 24 or worse according to others).

Transparency is king

Meet your voters for this week, and guffaw in delight at how foolishly you think they voted. If you can't see the embedded votes, visit the Google Docs site for reference.

Your turn - Help shape our BlogPoll and right our wrongs

How does the OBNUG poll look? Any teams that need to go up? Any that should go down? Share your thoughts in the comments.