Weekend comment thread: Pick three Broncos from the past to help Boise State in the present
Not that this year's version of the Boise State football team needs much help winning conference championships and busting BCS bowls, but still, imagine how great things would be if you could add three all-timers to the roster. Nevada would go down so hard!
The question: If you could pick three former Bronco players to join this year's team, who would they be?
All players are eligible, provided they are former Broncos and not on the current roster. No Kellen Moore clones, okay? Share your picks in the comments, and continue reading for picks from me and the Statesman guys.
The inspiration for this question came from an Idaho Statesman college football chat a few weeks back. Here is the original question and the two responses from Chadd Cripe and Brian Murphy.
So to recap ...
- Chadd Cripe's three players would be TE Derek Schouman, WR Titus Young, and CB/S Quintin Mikell
- Brian Murphy's three players would be WR Titus Young, three other guys, maybe Kyle Wilson, and what do you all think about Tyler Jones.
Kevan's picks
Marty Tadman. Boise State needs a safety, and Marty Tadman is both a safety and my favorite player of all time. That works out pretty well. I suppose I could have gone with Quintin Mikell here, but I do not have a Quintin Mikell shrine in my den.
Ryan Clady. With one whole side of the offensive line gone, the Broncos could use some offensive line help. And Ryan Clady owes us a year anyway.
Ellis Powers. For whatever reason, I remain skeptical of Boise State's nickels. Hunter White may be great, and Dextrell Simmons could end up being legendary. But for the time being, I'd feel much more comfortable with Ellis Powers - the patriarch of nickels - atop the depth chart.
Your picks
What three players would you choose to add to this year's Boise State football team? Would the Broncos roll with the extra ammunition? Anyone willing to choose John Gott? Share your thoughts in the comments.
82 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I would bring back
Austin Pettis and Titus Young so Kellen had targets we were sure of. Then I bring back Korey Hall because he was an all everything LB that could stop the run and drop into coverage during passing downs.
"I think I know what you guys are trying to say.....We need to build a space helicopter." Nathan Explosion
"Pluto’s not even a planet no more, which I’m very disturbed about. I grew up when Pluto was a planet. Now, I’m 25, I turn around and Pluto’s no longer a planet. I’m going to elbow that guy in the nose." -Ron Artest
I don't go too far back.
I would take:
Austin Pettis
Kyle Wilson
Jared Zabransky……… Just so that he could play Georgi again, without the 8 interceptions, win by alot and correct the fung shue of the Bronco universe.
But in the present we have Kellen Moore. Zabransky would be holding a clipboard.
by Drew Roberts on May 13, 2011 8:18 AM PDT up reply actions
I sat through three years of Z's games
More than enough……
I would rather see Kellen hang 50 in the first half and give Z a shot at redemption.
by ElPepeGrande on May 13, 2011 12:30 PM PDT up reply actions
I’d love to have Titus back another year…his game had fully evolved and he was as dangerous a receiver as we’ve ever had.
On defense, I’d probably like to have Korey Hall back with Andy Avalos running a close second.
I’d round out my time machine squadron with Chris Carr…but only partially for his defensive skills. He was one heckuva return man.
Kevin, you would take Powers over Venable? Interesting...
I would take Young, Korey Hall, and Tyler Jones. I think our safeties are going to be fun to watch. King George will have one side of the field locked down and we’ll probably have Jeremy on the other side flying around trying to kill people. Besides, can you imagine Korey and Byron lining up next to each other? That would be ridiculous…ly awesome.
If I remember correctly ...
… Powers played every down, every series at nickel. Venable split time with a number of guys. Now, this could be more depth-related than anything, but I remember Ellis Powers as a great player whose time with the Broncos (in the role he was made to play) was too short.
"I did not send you to go-kart camp." - Maury Garner
Powers was pretty great
he was probably faster than Venable and still a big hitter. I think I liked Venable’s size a little better for the position. He was 5’11" 220, Powers was 5’10" 200.. Then again, Hunter White dropped pounds to play the position but I think Venable was a bigger hitter partly because of his size.
by 4EverBleedBlue on May 13, 2011 1:38 PM PDT up reply actions
I agree with the Marty Tadman pick. I would also like Chris Carr for the return game (the man was fearless) and bring back Jarvis Hodge. He was finally getting going in his senior year.
Honorable Mention would be Ryan Clady and Winston Venable.
"Gandhi didn't take a knee, Martin Luther King didn't take a knee, Thomas Edison didn't take a knee, and I sure as hell am not going to take a knee." -- Dan Hawkins
My three would be
1. John Rade
2. Korey Hall
3. Ryan Clady
BSU don't need smoke and mirrors to get the job done, they got orange pants.
by Belexes on May 13, 2011 9:01 AM PDT reply actions 2 recs
Love the Rade pick - Rexes for Belexes!
there is no 'Z' in 'Boise'
there is no 'O' in 'Petersen'
there is no edit button on SBNation
by Boise State of Mind on May 13, 2011 9:27 AM PDT up reply actions
First ever John Rade reference on this blog
Congrats.
"I did not send you to go-kart camp." - Maury Garner
hall, clady & wilson...with IJ alternate
"High profile players demand high profile compliance", P. Dees, NCAA Chair. Refc. pending inquiries to tOSU, Auburn, USC...
by NotsoSchizo on May 13, 2011 9:05 AM PDT reply actions 1 recs
rec'd because this would be my exact pick.
"Or, if boarding the bus is just too difficult for an Establishmentarian to do, get your snob school to schedule the Broncos home-and-home. Any takers?" - Pat Forde
"I don’t need a dictionary, I have an ipad, and an expensive large university education." - hrman7
by reflectivity on May 13, 2011 10:05 AM PDT up reply actions
thx! in the words of your most devoted leg-humper..."you have style and reflectivity"
"High profile players demand high profile compliance", P. Dees, NCAA Chair. Refc. pending inquiries to tOSU, Auburn, USC...
by NotsoSchizo on May 13, 2011 11:03 AM PDT up reply actions 8 recs
ha!
cute.
"Or, if boarding the bus is just too difficult for an Establishmentarian to do, get your snob school to schedule the Broncos home-and-home. Any takers?" - Pat Forde
"I don’t need a dictionary, I have an ipad, and an expensive large university education." - hrman7
by reflectivity on May 13, 2011 7:55 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
if TM were a four legged humper instead of a two-legged one, what kind do you think he'd be?
great Dane? Chihuahua? irish water dog? spitz? bassett? american or english fox hound?
"High profile players demand high profile compliance", P. Dees, NCAA Chair. Refc. pending inquiries to tOSU, Auburn, USC...
by NotsoSchizo on May 16, 2011 11:36 AM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
I think he'd be a weener dog.
jk :)
If you don't like something, change it. If you can't change it, change the way you think about it. Maya Angelou
BSU changes the BCS! 2011
spare time and a bum knee...
"High profile players demand high profile compliance", P. Dees, NCAA Chair. Refc. pending inquiries to tOSU, Auburn, USC...
by NotsoSchizo on May 17, 2011 11:55 AM PDT up reply actions
Give Doug some bigtime holes and Kellen lots of time
I would take Ryan Clady and Derek Schouman because both were excellent in run blocking, and Schouman was the most versatile tight end we ever had (imho). Harsin once called them “our two best guys” (referring to blocking) in the 2006 season. Shoring up the offensive line like that would give Dough gaping holes to run through, and Kellen enough time to pick apart the defense no matter who he was throwing to. I agree with 4everbleed that I don’t think safety will be a big issue, and I am confident that the nickel position will be fine too. I think bringing back Kyle Wilson would effectively shut down one side of the field, making it much easier for the safeties as well.
So my three would be Clady, Schouman, and Kyle Wilson. Alternate would be Titus because the receivers are still unproven. It’s the guys in the trenches that win games, and we might have the best O-line and D-line in the nation with those guys back.
by MyDadTaughtAtBSU on May 13, 2011 9:08 AM PDT reply actions
Jon Helmandollar – Because he’s a friend and I need on-field connections.
Daryn Colledge – Because I want to keep Kellen as safe as possible and Daryn is a beast.
Titus Young – Just in case the other receivers need a little more time to develop.
"Whatever happened to just winning games."
ew you just made me feel bad
Yeah, I guess I need to change out Jerry Smith for Titus Young. I’m kind of related to the guy, PLUS if he had a Kellen Moore throwing to him, he really would be a blast to watch.
by 4EverBleedBlue on May 13, 2011 10:12 AM PDT up reply actions
Don't feel bad.
I chose to bring Jon back for my own selfish reasons (although his dedication, heart and work ethic would be a great advantage). Tyler Jones is a 5th (or something like that) cousin of mine but I didn’t pick him because I don’t really know him.
"Whatever happened to just winning games."
by Broncochick on May 13, 2011 10:29 AM PDT up reply actions
Titus Young
Kyle Wilson
2006 Ian Johnson
My grandfather was a Packers fan, my father is a Vikings fan, I am a Lions fan, and there is no way in hell I am raising a Bears fan.
Oh, and I hate the Philadelphia Eagles
2006 Ian Johnson
That “2006” part cannot be stressed enough.
"I did not send you to go-kart camp." - Maury Garner
call me crazy
but i’d still take Doug Martin
Thank you, Nick Adenhart. You will always be remembered. #34
by howiestheman on May 13, 2011 12:47 PM PDT up reply actions
DaWuan Miller
I would bring the one arm wounder and move him to wide receiver…. We have to do something to challenge Kellen.
by Jay Weston on May 13, 2011 9:35 AM PDT reply actions 5 recs
huge get.
I once took a Dawuan elbow nub to the chin in a game of pick-up basketball. He used it as a weapon. He also had a pick 6 against North Texas if I remember right?
my dad has a nub like that. i feel your pain.
"Or, if boarding the bus is just too difficult for an Establishmentarian to do, get your snob school to schedule the Broncos home-and-home. Any takers?" - Pat Forde
"I don’t need a dictionary, I have an ipad, and an expensive large university education." - hrman7
by reflectivity on May 13, 2011 7:55 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Clady, Carr and Young.
"Boise State football is now a Fargo winter. You know what's coming, and that information does you no good whatsoever". Matt James / The Fresno Bee
I can't believe I am going to agree with Murph...
Safety would be first with Quintin Mikell. I hate to snub Tadman, but Mikell was always right where you wanted him to bed (just like Visa) and he was a little more physical against the run.
Lockdown corners don’t come around often so Kyle Wilson is a must.
with uncertainty in the kicking game my third selection would be Tyler Jones. His KO length in the kick coverage game can really help out the defense too. Brotzman’s versatility as a punter would also give him consideration.
"...east and west is the problem, north and south the solution."
There are good candidates out there
I think the offense is in good hands with Kellen, but I am going to give him that downfield threat with Titus which will make our current guys better, and then I’ll sure up the defense by adding Quinten Mikell because he is our best safety in my opinion and add Wilson so we have a shut down corner. (I’ll trust Byron Hout doesn’t break his foot this year so I’ll leave Korey Hall out, but he would be my 4th choice. Would love to see Hout and Hall on the field at the same time- one of them always blitzing.)
Our quarterback goes to 11 !
As much as I love martin
Id bring back brock forsey. With doug n forsey back there, wow. when I think of what the broncos have done I always thinls of brock. A local talent that nobody wanted n nobody could stop him. He in my opinion is the beat bronco all time. Him, martin and maybe dj, come on
"dont talk about it, be about it"
by bmc83 on May 13, 2011 11:30 AM PDT via mobile reply actions
hmmmm.....
Very interesting topic. Two answers:
Need, based on the current roster:
Clady We need a road grater up front
Wilson Shutdown corners are a must
Jeremy Childs (Titus is a good pick, but everyone already picked him)
Personal preference, because it would be fun to see these guys on today’s team:
Colledge, because I really liked watching him play.
Mikell, because he was amazing, and I think he would be even more effective with the defensive front that we have now.
Korey Hall because he would be deadly behind today’s line.
tough question..
Given the need for OL help, I’d say Clady is a must. We need a safety, and I do loves me some Marty Tadman, but is Mikell a smarter pick? And even at that, JJ was an INCREDIBLE player. That one’s a toss up. For the last one, I can’t decide whether to go the WR route (with Titus, most likely, but Pettis was super reliable…) or the NB route (I’d take Winston Venable all day).
Okay, okay, okay… final picks:
Ryan Clady
Marty Tadman
Austin Pettis.
Clady busts open huge holes, Tadman fills out need for a safety/general awesomeness and Pettis provides a steady, reliable #1 receiver for Kellen.
Thank you, Nick Adenhart. You will always be remembered. #34
I'll give it a try



…with the 351 cu.in, of course…
I’m not sure how they actually can help, but all three are pretty old and this is the best I could come up with being a so-called rival and all. You’re welcome.
"If we score, we may win. If they never score, we'll never lose."
-Erk Russell
by DavetheDawg on May 13, 2011 12:52 PM PDT reply actions 8 recs
Ford Bronco?
That is ok we have Doug on the team for 1 more year. However they will both run over Idaho DB’s with about the same force.
"Every Damn Day."- Coach Pete
by Broncograd96 on May 13, 2011 8:33 PM PDT up reply actions
Not for need but for wants
I’ll pick these three only because I miss watching them but they would also make a good run at a roster spot.
Quinton Mikel is a must. He was the first big time recruit that I remember having Pac-10 interest. He was the best open field tackler BSU ever had. (Are you listening Julius Brown).
Dempsey Dees. Good cover corner for the time and straight up ghetto name.
K.C Adams. One of Pokey’s JC recruits with a little baggage and a lot of quicks.
Besides Mikel who is a lock for a starting position on this years team, the other selections just add a whole lot of “character” to the squad.
i think illoka may have a valid arguement
About not being even considered for best bsu open field tackler of all time!
Most under rated Bronco of all time too, maybe?
"As soon as they're in the open field, nobody is going to catch them. Doug, even if somebody is right in front of him, he might run him over."
- Travis Stanaway
by TooMuchYoung on May 14, 2011 3:11 AM PDT via mobile up reply actions
Just because the names are fun to say with funny accents
- Jeb Putzier
- Kimo von Oelhoffen
- Shaunard Harts
and even tho it makes 4 you cant not have a College Football Hall of Famer Randy Trautman!!
by TX Bronco! on May 13, 2011 4:48 PM PDT reply actions 1 recs
Coaches?
Why not bring back the coaches who coach these guys?
I started with one, played on the same team with two of them, and worked with all three of them. My picks are
Huff
Kwiatkowski
Yates
Cornerback, Safety, and Linebacker are holes for Boise State
Doug Hawkins, Quentin Mikell, and Kyle Wilson
Kevan's Picks
Kevan your picks are almost right on. Give me Quinten Mikell (beast of a saftey), Ryan Clady (beast in general) and Gerald Alexander (Heavy hitter that gets the nod over Jeron Johnson on account of never being ejected. And quite frankly I would like his mother to come back and re-open her Louisiana Fried Chicken cafe.)
by Bring the HAMMER! on May 13, 2011 5:55 PM PDT reply actions
Done and done.
Quintin Mikell…my favorite of all time.
Marty Tadman…my other favorite of all time.
Austin Pettis…the essence of clutch.
That’s one BAMF’ing safety duo.
by ThePhlipinSituation on May 13, 2011 7:14 PM PDT reply actions
lots of good guys...
I would want to bring back some guys that didnt get the chance to shine or didnt get to play with the current overall more talented teams…
1) E. Powers…one year at the brand new nickle hybrid spot wasnt enough, oh how far the nickle has come.
2) Q. Mikell…before his time as far as talented Broncos go.
3) D. Shouman… Moore would have made him the best tightend in all of the land.
Has anyone mentioned cloning Doug Martin yet? It wasnt expressly forbidden in the instructions?
Also, as an aside, I would take College over Clady. College either gave up 0 or 1 sack his entire bsu career and didnt have even a tenth as many untimely holding and false start penalties!
"As soon as they're in the open field, nobody is going to catch them. Doug, even if somebody is right in front of him, he might run him over."
- Travis Stanaway
by TooMuchYoung on May 14, 2011 3:24 AM PDT via mobile reply actions
and played a full season more....
Colledge seemed like the better college player, while Clady is the better pro.
Remember Colledge vs Swantek from Oregon State? ESPN showed Colledge eating his lunch, and then Swantek throwing his helmet on the sideline.
by ElPepeGrande on May 16, 2011 10:10 AM PDT up reply actions
Ryan Clady-Hamster running behind this guy would be scary
Titus Young-Pettis’ loss is softened by Kirby and Shoe, but the NFL caliber deep threat made Moore even more dangerous last yera
Quentin Mikell-worried about the secondary, J Johnson would have been a close call here as well
Boise State is 38-2 in my 3 years of college.
by warriorsscore110 on May 14, 2011 8:10 AM PDT reply actions
My First 3 Were Titus, Clady, and Wilson
But then I discovered:

by MooreWalksOnWater on May 14, 2011 8:52 AM PDT reply actions 1 recs
How about?
Clady, College and Caves ( that’s right Jeff Caves).
That last one.....sacrilege.
Shame, shame and more shame.
"Boise State football is now a Fargo winter. You know what's coming, and that information does you no good whatsoever". Matt James / The Fresno Bee
by blue4areason on May 15, 2011 9:30 AM PDT up reply actions
Wilcox called K. Hall the toughest guy he ever met
You always want a guy like that on your team.
But as far as needs go I think Clady or Shouman are both good picks. Next is TY.
With our strong front 7, I’m not too worried about DB next year.
How About
i would bring back…
1.Titus young. so kellen would have hiwat and young. two pretty decent recievers.
2. Kyle wilson..do i need to explain?
3. and, Ian Johnson. (imagine a wildcat that consisted of martin, harper, and johnson!)
Picks
Chris Carr – good returner & he was like glue in coverage
Quintin Mikell – smart & hard hitting
Tommy Galarda – very under rated, basically a lineman playing TE making spectacular catches for everything thrown his way. He solidifies your team without having to bring back an OL but you also get a good receiver in the mix.
#4 choice would be David Hughes at fullback
Could you imagine Hughes and Doug Martin in a back field – that would be punishing. No one would want to tackle either of them.
Which (somewhat) inverts my concerns; as areas of concern, I go in reverse order. I'm relying on 43 years of Boise State watching to
assure me will be OK at Wideout.
tvmunson
Bringing up some of the "old" guys
Lester “Smack” McNealy went to the pro’s out of BSU’s D backfield.
I saw him the other day, and he still looks like he could put a lickin’ on someone.
Randy Trautman could probably help out also…
Cedric Minter with Martin would really be a sweet backfield.
JMO
picks
Jeb Putzier… Big guy was fast
Ia Falo… Made every tackle on kick coverage
Sherm Blaser… For selfish reasons. I have the same hairline
Ia Falo, that guy was a stud.
"Boise State football is now a Fargo winter. You know what's coming, and that information does you no good whatsoever". Matt James / The Fresno Bee
by blue4areason on May 16, 2011 11:33 AM PDT up reply actions
Dear Bronco Nation
Please, please bring the Z back. He had the second highest completion percentage of any UGA QB in 2005. I’d rather have him than Kellen Moore every day of the week.
In your dreams, f&t.
If you don't like something, change it. If you can't change it, change the way you think about it. Maya Angelou
BSU changes the BCS! 2011
Oh well. We'll try to give Kellen the same welcome...
…though we may find him impervious to those particular charms.
by first and thom on May 17, 2011 5:16 AM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Nice to see some classy smack-for a change. "Georgia, Georgia.." (Munson at the guitar, inebriated)
tvmunson
UGA: Giving Boise Fans a Reason to Drink Since 2005
by first and thom on May 17, 2011 2:23 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
No, it' even more personal then that. If a Boise State fan has constipation, all he need do is replay the 1st half of
that game and he’ll (bw) until he loses cartilage.
tvmunson
this, from a man who recognizes classy smack?
However, I do agree with you.
If you don't like something, change it. If you can't change it, change the way you think about it. Maya Angelou
BSU changes the BCS! 2011
by boiseblues on May 17, 2011 3:58 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Rec'd for poignancy
You cannot reason a man out of something he didn't reason himself into in the first place.

by 


















