Five questions with Sports Illustrated's Stewart Mandel
Sports Illustrated's Stewart Mandel is one of college football's most brilliant minds, as evidenced by his saying only good things about the Broncos in SI's college football preview magazine. And guess what? He's got more good things to say, and he shares a bunch of them in an interview with OBNUG.
After the jump, find out what Mandel thinks about Kellen Moore's Heisman chances, what kind of pressure BSU faces on Labor Day night, and how likely it is for TCU to pass the Broncos in the polls. And share your thoughts on these topics and Mandel's answers. Read on.
In Sports Illustrated's college football preview edition, SI writer extraordinaire Stewart Mandel has Kellen Moore on his All-America team and picks two Boise State football games for his Games of the Year list. Hint: None of them are WAC games and none rhyme with Schmoledo.
Mandel writes regularly at SI.com, he has way more Twitter followers than Andy Staples, and wrote a book about college football that I will definitely get into once someone makes it into a movie.
Here is our conversation.
OBNUG: A lot of experts list Ryan Mallett, Jake Locker, Terrelle Pryor, Case Keenum, and Kellen Moore as the country's best quarterbacks, more or less in that order. You have Moore on your All-America team. Two-part question: 1) When did you first know you were a genius and 2) what was the deciding factor for you in putting Moore above the others?
I'm sure I'll only be a genius until the first time I write anything remotely negative about the Broncos.
I think most of the lists you're referring to are almost a reverse reaction to the early NFL draft rankings that came out last spring. Moore may not be a first-rounder like some of those guys, but seeing as he finished as the No. 2 passer last year with those ridiculous stats, whereas some of the other guys are being projected on "potential," Moore seems like the no-brainer PRESEASON All-American.
What series of events would have to happen in order for Kellen Moore to actually win the Heisman? Are we talking end-of-times scenarios here or would making the national championship game be good enough?
I don't think it's impossible, but it would have to go hand in hand with another undefeated season, and probably the championship game. Increasingly, those two races have been one and the same, as evidenced by Mark Ingram's win last year.
What kind of ramifications (both in national perception and in the polls) would there be if Boise State lost to Virginia Tech? What about if they won?
There's an inordinate amount of pressure on them going into that game. The pollsters have taken an unprecedented step of raking them in the top 3/5, and if they lose, there's going to be an immediate "thanks for nothing" reaction from a lot of pollsters.
They will probably drop at least 10-12 spots, which is pretty absurd, because if any brand name team lost to another top 10 team, its fall would be less (unless it's a huge blowout). If the Broncos win, thus begins the overriding debate of the 2010 season whether they deserve to play for the title.
If Boise State and TCU both head into conference play undefeated, is there any chance that the Horned Frogs jump the Broncos like they did last year? And if so, would I be justified in never following college football again?
Ha. Sure, there's a chance, but I do think that head-to-head result from last year's Fiesta Bowl will hover over both teams.
As for the second part, after everything you endure being a Boise State fan, right up to the great MWC migration possibly backfiring, it's admirable that you keep coming out every year as it is.
Any plans on coming out to Boise this year? I'll have LOST on Blu-Ray.
The Oregon State game is a definite possibility, but I'll be in D.C. first. I'll take you up on the Lost offer. Could Boise be the Hurley of 2010? After all this time as the fun little sidekick, he finally gets his chance to ... oh right, spoiler. Sorry.
Check out more from Stewart Mandel at SI.com, if you don't mind being in close proximity to Andy Staples, and follow Mandel on Twitter, if you have any idea how that works.
21 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
"...songs that soothe the savage soul." O Brother WAT
KL…thanks…really…thanks! I an ocean of so much corporately approved and rampant-jealous-fan negativity…you, OBNUG, and Stew provide the ONLY RAY OF HOPE about the truth coming into this seaon…IN 13 DAYS!!!
For some unknown anomaly, i was born and raised in TX, only to later see the light and escape to the Northwest that is my home now…albeit from afar b/c uncle san stuck me back down here. ANYWAY, i have more than enough personal observations over the decades of living as one and amongst the rednecks here and my biggest observation is this…
Homerism is at least an honest trade in college football, but the egoistic self-loving stitled blindness that is inured in TX football at all levels is immeasurably immense..and for that sad fact…hopeless for most native-borns to shake that DNA-strand off. AS SUCH, the tadpole/froggies overlook that the arguement FOR their program depends on riding the reputations of bigger TX teams for over-hyped national recognition—-BUT NOT EARNING THEIR OWN WAY. Thus, thinking they deserve better than they get, they croak loud and long about how dominant they are…forgetting that they are really just a brrrrrreeeeping noise in the night. I know, i’ve seen it, heard it discussed, and hammered into the innocent kids.
SO…THERE SHALT NOT BE LEAP-FROGGING!!!! especially from toads of any kind
To the right...my future brothers-in-law working hard on one of the trifecta of a Black & Gold birthright..."inebriation", yet before they acquired "nastiness" or "vandal-phrenia"
ryan mallet should not even be in the conversation. think jevan snead.
I'm all about covering the spread and moneylines. Glory favors the bold. Chance favors the prepared mind. Luck, well i have that too. University of Utah goes to the Pac-12 conference in 2011. I expect them to compete immediately for the conference CG. Brock Lesnar will defeat Cain Velasquez. Womens MMA, the next big thing in sports. 10 days till the first game of college football. UTAH vs Pitt. September 2nd 2010.
by wolfmanshowlforever on Aug 24, 2010 8:24 AM PDT reply actions 1 recs
ryan mallet is chump
and frankly he’s not that good of a QB
by Darth Prophet on Aug 24, 2010 4:56 PM PDT up reply actions
Nice work Kevan!!
Good interview with Stewart. It’s good to see there are national writers out there like Mandel and Pat Forde who don’t dismiss Boise State just because they aren’t in a “BCS conference.”
mark may actually said something nice about coach pete without smirking.
unbelievable. its a start.
I'm all about covering the spread and moneylines. Glory favors the bold. Chance favors the prepared mind. Luck, well i have that too. University of Utah goes to the Pac-12 conference in 2011. I expect them to compete immediately for the conference CG. Brock Lesnar will defeat Cain Velasquez. Womens MMA, the next big thing in sports. 1 week till the first game of college football. UTAH vs Pitt. September 2nd 2010.
by wolfmanshowlforever on Aug 26, 2010 4:45 PM PDT up reply actions
"Is this real life?"
Did OBNUG really have a blog interview with a SI writer? Seriously? This is insane!
by Rand McNalley on Aug 24, 2010 8:42 AM PDT reply actions 2 recs
Oh, it happened
Shhh, no one tell them that some of this site’s most popular posts involve Photoshopped cat pictures.
"Please put your fat finger down!" - Lars
No more kids games
I don’t see TCU leap frogging us due to the fact that we beat them last year- that is difficult to remove from one’s brain. We both have Oregon State and Wyoming on the schedule so there will be some inevitable comparisons happening if both teams are undefeated down the stretch and they looked more impressive against those common opponents. We have VT on the schedule and they have Baylor. I think VT looks quite a bit more impressive here. The MWC is a stronger conference than the WAC, but not enough to create a game of leap-frog if both teams are undefeated. Boise State will not participate in a game of leap-frog with TCU; however we are happy to participate in the game of Red Rover with TCU and the rest of their conference mates.
Ah, Perry the platypus, as usual your timing is uncanny. And by uncanny, of course I mean... completely canny!
by flyfishferg on Aug 24, 2010 11:54 AM PDT reply actions 3 recs
Leap-Frog
Boise State will not participate in a game of leap-frog with TCU
I also suggest we steer clear of any participation in a game of leap-frog with a rhinoceros
"I said, if I were smart then I would save up for a piece of string and a rock to wind the string around. Everybody wants a rock to wind a piece of string around."
Don't worry
It’s simple, we won’t have to play leag “Frog” this year. BSU goes undefeated once again, and TCU goes undefeated once again. BSU finishes #1, TCU #2, then we can play each other again in the Desert. I really don’t think there will be an undefeated SEC, Big 12, or Ohio State team this year. Their top teams are much more evenly matched. Oklahoma worries me a little.
by HornedFrog1992 on Aug 24, 2010 4:01 PM PDT up reply actions
Unfortunately...
The SEC champ, regardless of their record, already is locked into one of the two slots for the NCG.
RE: Genius & remote negativity
Mandel’s comment that he’ll be considered a genius until he says anything “remotely negative” about the Broncos contained an element of truth, at least as far as this writer is concerned. I’d like to think that I’m more objective than that, but it occured to me that there is the remotest possibilty I may NOT be perfect and indeed may perhaps be guilty of hyper-boosterism. I do think Watson and her duplicitous and inherently inconsistent week-to-week takes on the Broncos merited my inimitiable attention. But as for the rest, I am going to endeavor to acknowledge honest, good faith reservations about the quality of our team w/o resorting to the nasty diatribes I’ve unleashed in the past, wishing visitations of vile outrage on their daughters, embryonic abberrations on their progeny, lingering despairing death upon them and theirs leading to an eternity of consummation in the flames of Hell itself…
This is going to be harder than I thought.
tvmunson
Keep it Real Munson
Can a leopard change its spots or a zebra change his stripes? If you bleed blue then let it flow; I say.
Ah, Perry the platypus, as usual your timing is uncanny. And by uncanny, of course I mean... completely canny!
by flyfishferg on Aug 24, 2010 2:20 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
you're just worried about that facebook hit-list in Columbia...
inimitiable = inimitable?
Adjective: So good or unusual as to be impossible to copy; unique. (notice there’s a normal everyday word that is synonymous with above ginormagantuan word in definition)
it’s words like that that’ll get you on that list…. What, too soon? Eh, when in Rome….
Let the Media's excuse begin...again: "It was Boise State's first game of the year!" whilst completely ignoring that it was VaTech's first game, as well.
by TheShrewdOne on Aug 24, 2010 9:30 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Yeah munson'd inimitable-my typing and my eyes are failing; I proofread that twice and still missed it
“my unique attention”-doesnt work for me. I was using a variation of an expression-“in his inimitable way”-that I’ve heard mant times. I was not trying to be gino…that word is too hard for my typing skills.
On substance, and this relates to some VT posts, I think what (bw) us off is that unlike the AQs, our PROGRAM gets downtripped in the discussions. In early 2000’s when we started to have success the line was “could they beat (fill in the blank)”. Well since ‘07 we’ve beat the Big 10 (or is it 12-Big someone) champ, the Mtn. West, champ, and the Pac 10 champ. So now its the SOS stuff. but ti all gets to the same place-to dwontrip our program, not just the specifics of a given team (as with the AQs). And you look at TCU last year-I dont recall any PROGRAM discussion.
So I’ll try to determine who is talking in good faith and who is gratuitously downtripping us.
tvmunson
Oh I agree...couldn't agree more, in fact.
I was just ribbing ya…and found a perfect opportunity to through in an ironic current events story (irony = social networking being utilized as gang/mafia “hit” communique).
Plus, your writing are the only ones in many, many years that forces me to utilize google to understand all of what is said. You know google isn’t supposed to be used as a dictionary…it’s supposed to be used for porn…and spell-check!
Let the Media's excuse begin...again: "It was Boise State's first game of the year!" whilst completely ignoring that it was VaTech's first game, as well.
by TheShrewdOne on Aug 25, 2010 12:19 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
I'm used to the Shrew by now; in fact I admire the way you bust (bw) (that seems to be a back
East expression; guys in Boise don’t seem to get it)
tvmunson

by 






















