Will Boise State make a clean sweep of WAC awards?
Award season is just around the corner, and after this week's games, the WAC will be naming its players of the year and coach of the year. Does Boise State deserve to sweep the awards?
After the jump, take a look at how each award race is shaping up and share your comments on how likely a Bronco sweep would be.
Offensive Player of the Year
Candidates
- Kellen Moore
- QB Colin Kaepernick, Nevada
- RB Ryan Mathews, Fresno State
The race for this year's WAC OPOY has been eerily reminiscent of those maddening JumboTron plane/waterboat/car races they have at sporting events. One minute the red one is the lead. The next minute, it's the yellow one. Would someone please just end the thing so that we can all mentally prepare for the hidden-ball-in-helmet video?
Mathews was the overwhelming favorite for this award at the season's halfway point, but as is Mathews M.O., he got injured and has fallen behind. Next in line was Kaepernick who spearheaded a revitalized Nevada team as it ran off eight straight wins. However, it appears that the player with the most momentum at the end of the season is Moore, who clearly outdueled Kaepernick in the de facto WAC championship.
The favorite? Moore. It would be an abomination if anyone other than Moore took home OPOY honors. In other words, it would be a lot like last year.
(Note: All three players should return next year, providing quite the hype-fest for Karl Benson and the WAC. Has he already printed the media guide cover?)
Defensive Player of the Year
Candidates
- Ryan Winterswyk
- DT D'Anthony Smith, Louisiana Tech
- LB Ben Jacobs, Fresno State
- S Shiloh Keo, Idaho
- DE Dontay Moch, Nevada
Out of the three WAC awards, I think this one will be the closest one to call. Each of the above four players has had a special season. Idaho's Keo is second in the WAC in tackles and has been the sole playmaker on a much-improved Vandal defense. Jacobs has been an animal, recording 82 tackles, 3 FFs, 3 FRs, and two blocked kicks; plus, the WAC loves choosing linebackers (see Solomon Elimimian last year). Smith is the most NFL-ready defensive player in the conference, and while his numbers aren't outstanding, his impact certainly has been. Moch leads the conference in TFLs and is in the top three in sacks.
And then there's Winterswyk. He currently leads the WAC in sacks (8.0) and sits second in TFLs (15). He has been a disruptive force all season long, hassling quarterbacks and stuffing the run. Has he been Boise State's best defensive player this season? I would say yes. And in a year when there is no clear-cut player deserving of WAC DPOY, wouldn't it make sense to choose the best player on the conference's best defense?
The Statesman unveiled its choices for WAC awards this week, and they come to a different conclusion than I did.
Boise State cornerback Kyle Wilson is the choice in a year without a dominant player. Wilson is an All-American whose production - three interceptions, two pass breakups, two touchdowns - doesn't show his true value.
Do you think Wilson has played better than Winterswyk this season?
Personally, I think that Wilson had a better 2008. Anyone who says that teams do not throw Wilson's way this season is absolutely wrong. Teams most certainly throw his way, and he has been surprisingly undisciplined with penalties and tackling at times this year. Don't get me wrong. Wilson is still an all-time great Bronco. I just don't see him deserving DPOY honors this season.
If we're talking about who is more valuable to the Broncos' defense, then I think Wilson might win. But as far as the player who has had the better season, I think that player is Winterswyk.
Is there another player on the Boise State defense you think has had a better year? Jeron Johnson? Billy Winn?
Coach of the Year
Candidates
- Coach Pete
- Robb Akey
- Chris Ault
The only reason I listed Ault above is that I can see some people giving him credit for bringing Nevada out of that 0-3 hole and running off eight straight wins. That said, I think the discussion is really between Robb Akey and Coach Pete.
But really, should it even be a discussion? No doubt Akey worked some miracles with the Vandals this year in bringing them to 7-5. However, he lost his team's three biggest games and only won one out of five games after becoming bowl eligible against a weak schedule. The Vandals lost by double-digits to the conference's three best teams, giving up 133 points combined to Nevada and Boise State. And to put the cherry on top, Idaho dropped its season finale at home against a three-win Utah State.
On the other hand, Coach Pete has gone undefeated with the youngest team in the country.
If the WAC is serious about awarding COY to the coach who had done the best job this season, the award will go to Coach Pete. Year in and year out, he pulls off an incredible job, and it would be a shame if he is punished for his consistency.
(Note: I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the turnaround that Hawaii's Greg McMackin has done with the Warriors. The season could not have started worse for UH - McMackin's homophobic/apologetic blunder at media days, the Warriors' 2-6 start, the loss of their starting quarterback. But four straight wins, including a victory over Navy, has Hawaii on the cusp of a bowl. Who would have thought that was possible a month ago?)
Your turn
Who do you think will win this season's WAC awards? Share your winners in the comments. Also, please weigh in on who you think has had the better season: Ryan Winterswyk or Kyle Wilson.
24 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This is the same league that didnt vote Pete Coach of theYear in
‘06 when he won the Bear Bryant award and has been conspicuously ignoring our players for POW all year. Ok they’ve gotten somewhat better recently bc not to do so would have been patently absurd. To describe this league as chicken-badword does a distinct disservice to chickens who are unintentional in their droppings.
tvmunson
No sweep for the Broncos...
I am still hoping that Moore only plays the 1st half this week, has about 4 touchdowns and 250 yards. I look for someone else in conference to have a huge game and win player of the week. Then Moore can win the POY without ever winning the weekly honor.
BSU’s depth on defense might prevent a Bronco from winning POY. I would like to see Winterswyk or Winn get the award. Wilson is the “face” of the defense and without a clearly dominant defensive player in the conference this year, voters may just stick with their preseason pick, giving an edge to Wilson.
You’re right that teams are throwing at Wilson more and he has some undisciplined penalties. He is still a lockdown corner, is physical, and he is put on an island on nearly every down. Teams throw at him, because the rest of the defense is loaded on the other side. I hope Gavins is up to the task next year, because I am not sure Thompson can fill that role.
Coach of the Year will go to Akey. The expectations are so high for BSU that it is nearly impossible for Coach Pete to exceed them. He has made the extraordinary a commonplace event and it it taken for granted by those that watch/cover the WAC. Isn’t the COY voted on by the coaches in the league? It is still a travesty that June Jones won it in 2006 when Coach Pete took the Broncos to the Fiesta Bowl in his first year as the head man.
Despite not sweeping the awards, I do think this will be the first year in a long time that the number of Broncos on the 1st Team All-WAC will reflect the dominance of BSU in the conference.
Kellen, both receivers and maybe a couple of o-line will be first team. Their might be a chance at TE also, but the Broncos spread the wealth there.
Defensively, Swyk, Winn, Wilson, Johnson and Venable should all be first teamers and the 2nd team should be littered with Broncos as well.
"...east and west is the problem, north and south the solution."
by MKingery on Dec 3, 2009 8:23 AM PST reply actions 1 recs
I'm interested to see the All-WAC team, too
Boise State’s defense is such an interesting case study with awards like this because of how much they rotate players in and out. The secondary should at least land Johnson and Wilson on the first team, if not Venable.
Think the Broncos will put any offensive lineman on the first or second teams?
"Only film the ones that are standing, Kenneth." - Tony Perkis
I don't think they'll get any
Maybe Thomas Byrd. I would have said Will Lawrence at the start of the year, but I think he’s tailed off.
"Only film the ones that are standing, Kenneth." - Tony Perkis
I think we are on the same schedule, Kevan. I’m usually enjoying my first cup of coffee when you post something new. Good times.
Anywhoo…
I’m really trying to take off my “Bronco Hat” put on my “Unbiased Hat”. I think it’s next to my “Undying Hatred of Anything Vandal” hat.
I really don’t see ANY way the Offensive POY can go to anyone but Moore. It was a travesty last year. There’s no way they make the same mistake TWICE. Especially after Crazy Legs’ 31 yd rushing effort against a real defense last weekend.
Defensive POY is a little more complicated. I absolutely agree with your thoughts on Wilson. Teams DO throw his way, and he has been burned a few times. He absolutely is one of the all time great Broncos, but not POY this year.
I really think it has to come down to Swyk and Jacobs. If I remember right, Jacobs was causing some havoc when BSU was down there. Ehhh, give it to Swyk. I see him every week. I see what he means to the D. I think my “Bronco Hat” snuk back on my head for a second.
Coach of the Year will probably end up going to the Mustachioed One. Nobody will say anything, and that will be a travesty. Pete absolutely deserves it, The ‘Stache will get it. I think the Vandals history plays a role here. They have been a grease fire for YEARS and were expected to be the same this year. Fine, let The ’Stache have this one. The Broncos OWN the Vandals. They proved it on the field and we all know the only people who don’t value domination on the field are the BCS and Oregon Duck fans. The ‘Stache is Pete’s whipping boy, always will be.
by MooreWalksOnWater on Dec 3, 2009 8:28 AM PST reply actions 1 recs
The more I talk about Jacobs ...
… the more I could see the WAC going his way. It’s really wide open. I would be interested to see the voting after all is said and done.
"Only film the ones that are standing, Kenneth." - Tony Perkis
WAC Award Committee motto to Bronco faithful:
“Get used to disappointment.”
Seriously, these coaches have soft hearts and put too much stock on sharing the love. They don’t care about the individuals successes and saying Boise has all the best players/coaches is another way of saying the truth: the WAC has no credibility outside of Boise State.
Boise will get shafted in multiple categories this year. With or without my Blue and Orange glasses on (gets very dizzy, btw)
"You know where i'm from, a little suspicion about one's true identity and motives is considered good manners."
-- Nale
Your Blue and Orange glasses go great with my Bronco Hat.
Now I need some Boise St jorts to complete the ensemble (I always to shirtless).
by MooreWalksOnWater on Dec 3, 2009 9:04 AM PST up reply actions
According to Pat Forde:
Boise State is terrific. The rest of the WAC is not.
That being said, he gave the coach of the year award to Rob Akey…
Someday I hope to look in a mirror and see something special... something like a coach pete protoge'.
For what it is worth
- OPOY: There is only one person in the WAC who could even legitimately be in the same coversation with Kellen Moore for this award and he anwers to the name of Austin Pettis. If Kellen doesn’t win this it will be an absolute travesty.
- DPOY: There isn’t any single player who really stands out above the crowd. I would lean toward Swyk because he has played well against the run and pass. In reality it will probably go to Moch, Jacobs, or Smith.
- COY: Like all of you have already stated, Coach Pete deserves this award unquestionably but people have been drooling all over Akey this entire season. Because the Vandals collapsed down the stretch Akey’s hype has been tarnished a bit and I would actually call this one as a toss up right now as to how the voting will actually go.
by Mountngrown on Dec 3, 2009 9:36 AM PST reply actions 1 recs
Akey’s finish is the only thing I can think of that would open the door. Had he not lost to Utah State, I think the award would have been his. Now? I think Coach Pete has a great shot of winning.
"Only film the ones that are standing, Kenneth." - Tony Perkis
If my estimation of the WAC is correct Akey has it.
If I’m wrong I will abjectly prostrate before the OBNUG community in humbly apology. Adn I’m no ttalking about “deserving” here; this is like the Academy Awards, where merit is only one, and sometimes barely that, of the innumerable considerations.
tvmunson
hard to give it to the mustache...
when you go 1-5 down the stretch. but i think people want him to have it so he will get it. i have been somewhat unimpressed by kyles penalties and a few obvious missed tackles. hope the nfl scouts forgive 2009.
by Finloopio on Dec 3, 2009 9:43 AM PST via mobile reply actions
Not positive that Ryan Matthews will be back next year...
Last I heard he was going to gauge his draft stock at year’s end.
I have no confidence in the WAC
They have the credibility than a Tijuana street-walker minus the hygiene. They have shown time and time again they are unable to transcend their obvious resentment of the Broncos success. Were it otherwise, but it isn’t.
tvmunson
Gotta give Akey-Breaky some props here
Pete is a better coach but the V’s surprised everyone and that usually means the coach gets the credit(although come to think o fit no obvious examples come to mind). Oh well Breaky gets it and it wouldn surprise me to see him leave.
tvmunson
I agree.
The Akey love comes from exceeded expectations. Everyone expected Coach Pete and the Broncos to do what they are doing. Everyone was expecting the Vandals to do what they have done in the past. If it was enough to impress Pat Forde, I have a feeling that will be enough to secure it in the WAC.
Catch me on the BroncoNation Podcast!
by OBNUG Intern on Dec 3, 2009 3:44 PM PST up reply actions 1 recs
One reason I wish we were in the MWC...
Notice the sweep the Horned Frogs got this year. They got all of them except Freshman of the Year. Apparently they don’t let their sore feelings get in the way of their voting.
Although, I guess the difference would be that TCU hasn’t won six of the last seven MWC titles. As Belexes said, they can’t beat us on the field, so they have to snub us where they can actually control the outcome.
Honestly, it’s fine with me. I think it helps us keep out blue collar mentality.
"Well, we'll just have to get to know each other a little better then. I like Ferris wheels, college football, and anything that goes more than 200 miles an hour."
Really?
Utah last year, BYU the two years before. TCU really can’t have won 6 of the past 7.
"You know where i'm from, a little suspicion about one's true identity and motives is considered good manners."
-- Nale
Nevermind.....
“hasn’t” Skipping words isn’t a good idea.
"You know where i'm from, a little suspicion about one's true identity and motives is considered good manners."
-- Nale

by 



















