Top 26 Poll: Wins over Idaho do matter!
Who says a win over one of the worst teams in Division I-A doesn't count for anything?
In the Bronco Blogger Top 26 Poll, Boise State's win over the Vandals was enough to propel them into the No. 6 spot, two places ahead of Utah, who rolled over SDSU last weekend. So apparently, beating up on a bad team is relative.
Oklahoma, who was on a bye, dropped a spot or two to make room for the Broncos. There was also a change at the top of the poll as Texas Tech moved to No. 1 while on their bye week, supplanting Alabama. Obviously, we don't know what we're doing.
You can visit the Top 26 poll homepage for more details or you can download the Top 26 poll pdf. There's a lot of personal responsibility here, which might not be a good thing this week.
- Texas Tech
- Alabama
- Florida
- Texas
- USC
- Boise State
- Oklahoma
- Utah
- Penn State
- Georgia
- Ball State
- Missouri
- Ohio State
- Oklahoma State
- Michigan State
- BYU
- TCU
- Pittsburgh
- Oregon State
- Cincinnati
- LSU
- Florida State
- Oregon
- Miami
- North Carolina
- Maryland
Also receiving votes: Georgia Tech, Tulsa
Say good-bye to: South Carolina, Wake Forest
OBNUG's Kevan takes the reigns this week in defending his poll from all those people who don't think Boise State should be the No. 3 team in the country. What do they know anyway?
- Texas Tech: The Big XII is stronger than the SEC (don't smite me, football gods), and Texas Tech is the best team in the Big XII. For this week, at least.
- Alabama: I put them at No. 2 out of obligation since they're undefeated. I would prefer they were at No. 8 or 9.
- Boise State: Is No. 3 too high for the Broncos? Hardly. The Broncos have showed no signs this year that they can't hang with any other team in the country. The rest of the schools below BSU cannot say the same.
- Florida: Imagine if they hadn't lost to Ole Miss. I can't. I was just wondering if you could.
- Utah: Their close wins against bad teams look much worse than the Broncos' close wins against mediocre teams.
- USC: Why aren't pollsters penalizing the Trojans for playing in a terrible conference when they do the same to teams like Boise State and Ball State? Double standard!
- Texas: They haven't looked the same since that game against Oklahoma State, and had they not beaten the Sooners, I would have ranked them lower.
- Oklahoma: It doesn't really matter where I rank them since they're just going to fold in a big game anyway.
- Ball State: I have yet to make up an exception to my "How to rank undefeateds" rule that would justify my ranking undefeated Ball State at No. 9.
- Penn State: I really wanted Joe Paterno to go out on a high note. Him and his artificial hip.
- Georgia: I was one of the few who didn't have Georgia as my preseason No. 1. I had LSU.
- Oklahoma State: Yeah, this seems about right.
- Missouri: Sure. Why not?
- BYU: I really hope BYU does not jump back into the BCS picture with an upset of Utah this weekend. That would be the pits.
- Ohio State: Oh, is the Michigan - Ohio State game this weekend? I couldn't tell.
- Michigan State: Why are they ranked so high? Even by me, I mean.
- Pittsburgh: I have no idea what I was doing from this point forward.
- TCU
- LSU
- Oregon State
- Florida State
- Cincinnati
- Miami (FL)
- Maryland
- North Carolina
0 recs |
4 comments
Comments
Holy geez…I forgot again. Time to get back on the meds.
a reminder email would've been nice, too.
by FightFightBSU on Nov 17, 2008 3:37 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I think #3 looks about right. Except BSU hasn't really had a close game this year, not in the final quarter anyway.
by Jeremy on Nov 17, 2008 3:46 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
Uh, dude, careful…
BSU ahead of Florida and USC? I'm a Boise State fan, but I try to remain realistic -the Broncos would get KILLED by USC, Florida, and Texas. Seriously, it would be embarassing!!!
It would be nice, though, if we could avoid the 'doubt' issue altogether… I've been arguing for years that BSU deserves a spot in the PAC 10. I don't want it to get to the point where BSU monopolizes the non-BCS conference bid for BCS bowl games; however, It seems as though this is innevitable until BSU gets the BCS conference elevation that it has earned.
by Patrick on Nov 17, 2008 8:55 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
That's where I struggle with my poll: figuring out whether to rank teams based on what they've done on the field or what they'd do if they faced each other. I went with the former, and I consider BSU going undefeated to be a stronger credential than Florida being great but losing to Ole Miss.
That's the long answer. The short answer is that I am not realistic.
by kevanlee on Nov 17, 2008 9:11 PM PST reply actions 0 recs













